Short-Order Kitchen
Big Mac-Style Sloppy Joes

- Servings
- 4 to 6
- Prep
- 15 minutes, plus 30 minutes chilling the sauce
- Cook
- 15 to 20 minutes
- Method
- Skillet
- Heat
- Medium-high heat (buns at 400°F)
- Difficulty
- Easy
Part 4 of the thread Drive-thru copycats, lightened up
- Make the special sauce first and chill it at least 30 minutes.
- Brown the meat, then stir in onion, chopped pickles, cheese and some sauce.
- Toast the buns at 400°F while the meat cooks.
- Lean turkey makes it even lighter than beef.
Ingredients
Special sauce
Sloppy joe mix
To serve
You'll need
- Blender or food processor
- Large skillet
- Baking sheet
- Knife and cutting board
Directions
Sauce
- Blend all the sauce ingredients until smooth. Chill at least 30 minutes.
Sloppy joes
- Heat the oven to 400°F and toast the buns lightly.
- Brown the meat in a sprayed skillet with salt, pepper, garlic powder and Worcestershire.
- Stir in the onion, pickles, cheese and 8 tablespoons of sauce until hot and combined.
- Spread more sauce on the buns, add lettuce and cheese if you like, and pile on the meat.
- Serve right away.
wesellis.com/blog/big-mac-sloppy-joes/
Everything that makes the famous burger taste like itself is in the sauce, the pickles and the shredded lettuce. The two patties and the middle bun are mostly architecture. So this skips the architecture and puts the flavor into a skillet.
The sauce needs a head start
Make the sauce before anything else. Straight out of the blender it tastes like mayo and ketchup. After half an hour in the fridge, the onion and relish settle in and it starts tasting like the thing you're after. It keeps about a week, so a double batch isn't a bad idea.
Tip
Blend it rather than whisking. The minced onion breaks down and the sauce goes smooth and pale orange, the way it should look.
Pickles in the meat, not just on top
Chopping the pickle chips and stirring them right into the filling is what makes this read as a burger instead of a regular sloppy joe. Every bite gets a little of that sour crunch.
The same sauce idea shows up on the bunless Flying Dutchman, which leans on thick grilled onion rounds instead of bread. And if you want the burger flavor with a lot more lettuce, the Cheeseburger Salad is a good place for any leftover sauce.
Heads up
Drain the pan if the meat throws off much fat before you add the sauce, or the filling turns greasy and thin.
- Cheeseburger QuesadillasShort-Order Kitchen
- In-N-Out-Style Flying Dutchman, BunlessShort-Order Kitchen